Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rebecca Hubbard's avatar

I dont think ten stories was ambitious for us to read, but perhaps for you to go through and then write? Just don't burn yourself out. Dealing with these stories day in and day out can start to really impact one's mental health. I know mine is shot.

There were a few stories that really resonated with me. The following are my thoughts on these events:

The release of a Tunisian man from Guantanamo after 23 years and with no due process. This is terrible and terrifying all in one article bc it means it can happens to anyone in America. I feel we owe this man as a country for the years taken from him that he can never get back. Though I do not know how this could ever be made up for or if anything could make this man whole. As a veteran I'm deeply troubled by Guantanamo. As soldiers we take an oath to protect the CONTITUTION. A document which gives power and voice to the rights of Americans. If these rights are so fundamental to one's existence as that document attests, why were this man's rights violated for 23 years. Why are there no repercussions for such an atrocity?

The OH governor signing that dumb bill. Forgive my frankness. When I saw that yesterday, I sent the article to my sister immediately who lives in Columbus. There is absolutely no reason why a police force, paid with tax dollars already, can't complete these tasks without charging for them. Honestly, how is this not another "tax" for their services? I guess I just don't understand how they're being paid to do their job twice??? And the only reason to request this is suspicion of a police officer violating his duties. I'd think we'd want to ensure our police force were of the best quality and training however, since they are not even legally required to protect citizens, that's a joke. This just creates further obstacles for anybody who's rights have been violated. Protect the oppressor, not the oppressed seems to be the order of the day.

The man that went to prison for harassing and robbing his tenants of their identities, money, and dignity. This man belongs in prison. Periodt. However, I would find it more productive and society better as a whole, if he were forced to recognize and then reconcile with his hatred in a more reformative and restorative system. Instead, he will be placed in a system where he will join like minded men and they will feed off of each other. Eventually, the men he's come in contact with in prison will be released. More than likely they will carry on with hatred and violence. Recidivism is another tool of oppression. The cycle will repeat. We need to to try something better. For all our sakes.

The Amish community that built the small homes in under 48 hours in NC. If this is possible, and for the amounts represented, why are we not working with these communities to help our unhoused population and/or the "housing shortage" (really just an issue of private equity using the housing market to keep everyday Americans from buying and perpetually renting but that's another topic). The Amish are incredibly skilled builders that wouldn't throw up a few boards and call it house either. The point is, clearly this is possible and can be accomplished. With the fires in CA and the LA government redistributing money from the shelter fund for the unhoused crisis and from the fire department fund into the LA police fund ppl in CA need places for shelter from the fires more than ever.

Anyways, that's just my two cents on the topics that stuck out to me. I appreciate your time and energy. I hope this next four years is not as terrible as we all believe it will be, but nobody is saving us so we have to save ourselves. Accurate information and access to it are so important right now. It seems our avenues for educating the public keep coming under attack from the billionaire class and that is a frightening development. Take care in the new year and find community of you haven't one already.

Rebecca

Expert Level Bummer's avatar

The problem is that prisons reinforce the systemic inequalities that allow people like this to get away with what they do. Prisons are the cudgel over the heads of the homeless, threatening them with being shuffled off into slave labor for being in financial crisis. Prisons even reinforce this landlord's ability to take advantage of tenants because landlords like this tend to have law enforcement on their side, and they will hold the threat of arrest and/or eviction over people's heads.

Incarceration doesn't make whole the person who was harmed by the actions of the incarcerated. Incarceration will never be used against people who do things like this in the same manner it's used against marginalized communities. As long as the institution exists, it will always be used against marginalized people first. That's why we fight for abolition. We know there are better approaches that focus on restoration and justice. Putting people into a box for years doesn't solve things, and so many people are being shoved into the box because it exists. The idea behind abolition isn't (necessarily) to just open every door and set everyone free. It's finding a way to make a system that prioritizes community care and restorative justice over punitive retribution.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?